Share charters - sell by the seat
List a per-seat price and set the boat's capacity - eight rods, ten, whatever the survey allows. Seats sell one, two, four at a time until the trip is full, and a 15-minute checkout hold with a visible countdown stops two groups from buying the same last seats.
Half-full trips stop being a mystery: the calendar shows exactly how many seats are left on Saturday's 6am snapper run.